• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Olde Bay Cafe

Nestled in Dunedin, FL, Olde Bay Cafe brings a fresh take on seafood in a cozy waterfront setting. Offering a diverse menu of tacos, New American dishes, and delectable seafood options, this hidden gem has earned praise for its flavorful mahi sandwich and shrimp tacos. With outdoor seating overlooking the water, guests can enjoy a relaxing dining experience. The friendly staff and relaxed atmosphere make it a perfect spot for a casual meal or drinks. From fresh-caught grouper to mouthwatering shrimp tacos, Olde Bay Cafe promises a satisfying culinary experience that keeps guests coming back for more.

Olde Bay Cafe: Reviews & Ratings

Christina B.
Christina B.

As locals, we decided to take a bike ride along the trails and stopped at Olde Bay Café for a quick lunch and a cold drink. We were not disappointed! The shrimp tacos were delicious, and the mahi sandwich was perfectly cooked and flavorful. It was the perfect spot to refuel and relax while enjoying the waterfront views. We'll definitely be back! Staff were friendly and did an excellent job!

Mike M.
Mike M.

This is a great little seafood spot right on the water in Dunedin. They have mostly outdoor seating in a few spots on the inside of this cozy dining establishment. Food is fresh and there are no fryers so don't expect any kind of fried foods, but the food you will get our delicious! Great selection of draft beers to wet the pallet, as well as some wines and sangrias as well.cocktails are also available as I do have a full liquor bar. This place is a little bit on the small side. You may have to wait a little bit, but that just gives you a reason to walk around the pier area while your table is prepped.

Rachael G.
Rachael G.

Very cute place on the water and best kept secret to come here after the crazy Dunedin parades as it's a short walk away and never a long wait but shhhhh don't tell anyone. They make great drinks too like a margarita highly recommend. I got the burger wrap and I've gotten the Cuban sandwich before too. Both are amazing and I always ask for more of their dijonaise on the side. Good prices, pretty atmosphere on the water with lights at night and good music if you like alternative.

John H.
John H.

Went for lunch and got a seat along the railing overlooking the water. We put our name in as they were full, but our seats opened up within a minute or two. Good selection of beer and wine and menu selections of seafood and non-seafood items. I got the 6 oz. Mahi sandwich, and it was a beautiful chunk of fish with a great sauce and fresh veggies. Definitely needed my fork and napkins. My wife got the Shrimp Salad Wrap, and she said it was delicious. The dijonaise was a great accompaniment. The servers checked in 6-8 times, and the patio had a very casual and fun vibe.

Jillian B.
Jillian B.

i love this place. the food is always fresh and tasty, the service is always friendly, and the casual waterfront experience can't be beaten. i've eaten here several times and brought several out-of-town guests... it's so nice to be able to eat right on the water without paying an arm and a leg or getting fancy tiny entrees. everything we've tried has been delicious, particularly the grouper: it's fresh-caught, and you can tell for sure. it's so good. most recently, i also had the shrimp tacos, and i could literally eat them every day they were so tasty. the key lime slaw was like a little flavor bomb on top of the seasoned shrimp, and the avocado on top was the perfect hit of creaminess. so filling, so yummy. drinks are a bit expensive, but not necessary to enjoy the meal. this has been one of my favorite finds downtown and i'm happy to keep coming back.

Lawrence U.
Lawrence U.

Food here was fresh and served fast. Ordered the crab cake. Good sized patty. Well seasoned. The extenders was not overpowering. The salsas was fresh and a good balance. Did not need dressing. Price was on the higher end. The best part about this place is the location. Right by the water, relaxing, and chill. Our server was engaging, friendly and fast.

Valerie W.
Valerie W.

Located right at the Dunedin Marina, literally a stone's throw from the Best Western Hotel, this was a wonderful spot for a quick, convenient, casual meal and/or lazy afternoon cocktails. We ate there twice, once as a group of nine and then as a smaller group of four. Both times, our orders were taken quickly and efficiently, wonderful service with a smile. Nothing "gourmet deluxe," but a PERFECT option if you're in the area and want a reasonably priced, DELICIOUS, locally-sourced (I assume...) meal. Give 'em a try if you're in the area!!

Location

If you're in Dunedin, FL and craving some delicious seafood with a New American twist, look no further than Olde Bay Cafe. Located at 51 Main St, this hidden gem offers a mouthwatering menu of tacos and seafood dishes that will leave you wanting more.

With the option for takeout, outdoor seating, and a full bar, Olde Bay Cafe provides a cozy dining experience with waterfront views that simply can't be beaten. From fresh shrimp tacos to perfectly cooked mahi sandwiches, every dish is a culinary delight.

Customer reviews rave about the friendly staff, great selection of draft beers, wines, and cocktails, as well as the fresh and flavorful food. Whether you're looking for a quick lunch stop or a relaxed dinner by the water, Olde Bay Cafe is the perfect spot to refuel and unwind.

Don't miss out on the opportunity to try the grouper, the fresh-caught star of the menu, or indulge in the tasty shrimp tacos with key lime slaw and creamy avocado. With a casual and fun vibe, Olde Bay Cafe is a must-visit destination for seafood lovers in Dunedin.